Winners Round #1
| Division | Conference | Name |
| Independent | Brigham Young Cougars | |
| NAIA | Frontier Conference | Montana Tech Orediggers |
| Great Plains Athletic Conference | Dakota Wesleyan Tigers | |
| Heart of America Athletic Conference | Culver-Stockton Wildcats | |
| Kansas Collegiate Athletic Conference | Ottawa Braves | |
| Mid-South Appalachian Conference | Kentucky Christian Knights | |
| Mid-South Conference | Faulkner | |
| Mid-States Football Association | Indiana Wesleyan Wildcats | |
| North Star Athletic Association | Dakota State University | |
| Sooner Athletic Conference | Texas Wesleyan Rams | |
| Sun Conference | St. Thomas Bobcats | |
| NCAA I – FBS | American Athletic Conference | Memphis Tigers |
| Atlantic Coast Conference | Florida State Seminoles | |
| Big 12 Conference | Kansas State Wildcats | |
| Big Ten | Michigan Wolverines | |
| Conference USA | Western Kentucky Hilltoppers | |
| Mid-American Athletic Conference | Western Michigan Broncos | |
| Mountain West Conference | San Jose State Spartans | |
| Pac-12 Conference | Oregon Ducks | |
| Southeastern Conference | Mississippi Ole Miss Rebels | |
| Sun Belt Conference | Texas State – Bobcats | |
| NCAA I – FCS | ASUN Conferernce | Eastern Kentucky University |
| Big Sky | Northern Arizona Lumberjacks | |
| Big South | Campbell Fighting Camels | |
| Colonial Athletic Association | University of Delaware Blue Hens | |
| Mid-Eastern Athletic Conference | Howard Bison | |
| Missouri Valley Football Conference | Southern Illinois Salukis | |
| Northeast Conference | Duquesne Dukes | |
| Ohio Valley Conference | Southeast Missouri State | |
| Patriot League | Georgetown Hoyas | |
| Pioneer Football League | Drake Bulldogs | |
| Southern Conference | Citadel Bulldogs | |
| Southland Conference | McNeese State Cowboys | |
| Southwestern Athletic Conference | Florida A&M Rattlers | |
| The Ivy League | Princeton Tigers | |
| NCAA II | Central Intercollegiate Athletic Association | Lincoln Lions |
| Great American Conference | Southeastern Oklahoma Savage Storm | |
| Great Lakes Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Ferris State Bulldogs | |
| Great Lakes Valley Conference | Missouri S & T Miners | |
| Great Midwest Athletic Conference | Ashland Eagles | |
| Great Northwest Athletic Conference | Central Washington Wildcats | |
| Gulf South Conference | West Florida Argonauts | |
| Lone Star Conference | UT Permian Basin Falcons | |
| Mid-America Intercollegiate Athletics Association | Nebraska Kearney Lopers | |
| Mountain East Conference | West Virginia State Yellow Jackets | |
| Northeast-10 Conference | Franklin Pierce Ravens | |
| Northern Sun Intercollegiate Conference | Minnesota State Mankato | |
| Pennsylvania State Athletic Conference | Kutztown Golden Bears | |
| Rocky Mountain Athletic Conference | Colorado School of Mines Orediggers | |
| South Atlantic Conference | Mars Hill Lions | |
| Southern Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Kentucky State Thorobreds | |
| NCAA III | American Rivers Conference | Luther College Norse |
| American Southwest Conference | Mary Hardin-Baylor Crusaders | |
| Centennial Conference | Franklin & Marshall Diplomats | |
| College Conference of Illinois and Wisconsin | Carroll Pioneers | |
| Commonwealth Coast Conference | Nichols Bison | |
| Eastern Collegiate Football Conference | Gallaudet Bison | |
| Empire 8 Athletic Conference | Saint John Fisher Cardinals | |
| Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference | Defiance Yellow Jackets | |
| Liberty League | Buffalo State Bengals | |
| Massachusetts State Collegiate Athletic Conference | Worcester State Lancers | |
| Michigan Intercollegiate Athletic Association | Alma Scots | |
| Mid-West Athletic Conference | Beloit Buccaneers | |
| Middle Atlantic Conference | Misericordia Cougars | |
| Minnesota Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Saint Olaf Oles | |
| New England Small College Athletic Conference | Bates Bobcats | |
| New England Women's & Men's Athletics Conference | Merchant Marine Acad Mariners | |
| New Jersey Athletic Conference | The College of New Jersey Lions | |
| North Coast Athletic Conference | Oberlin Yoemen | |
| Northern Athletics Collegiate Conference | Lakeland Muskies | |
| Northwest Conference | Pacific Lutheran Lutes | |
| Ohio Athletic Conference | Mount Union Purple Raiders | |
| Old Dominion Athletic Conference | Washington & Lee Generals | |
| Presidents' Athletic Conference | Carnegie Mellon Tartans | |
| Southern Athletic Association | Rhodes Lynx | |
| Southern California Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Claremont-Mudd-Scripps Stags | |
| Upper Midwest Athletic Conference | Greenville Panthers | |
| USA South Athletic Conference | Methodist Monarchs | |
| Wisconsin Intercollegiate Athletic Conference | Wisconsin Whitewater Warhawks |